Reality TV DavidAmericanIdol.jpg

So what did you watch last night: Dancing With the Stars or American Idol?

Well, Kristi won for DWTS just like we had hoped - go her! And as for AI, we agree with judge Simon Cowell... it was David Archuleta's night, no contest!

The 17-year old performed Elton John's "Don't Let the Sun Go Down on Me," the ballad "In This Moment" and, finally, John Lennon's "Imagine." Not that rocker David Cook (eight years older at 25) performed poorly, of course; we just think Archuleta has what it takes to win.

Tell us your opinion! Which David will be the next American Idol?