Hayden Panettiere MCyrus090509_06_X17.jpg

Hayden Panettiere, Miley Cyrus, Charlize Theron and Justin Timberlake are just a few of the A-listers who showed up to the 5th Anniversary of Fashion Rocks in NYC the other night.

Though I adore Hayden and Miley, they don't consistently wow me with their red carpet style, but it's pretty safe to say that they both got it right this time with their dazzling, dark metallic silver dresses. The only question is who wore it better?