Posted on Mon May 11th, 2009 4:00pm PDT
...or not so much. C'mon, Nic, I know it's only a little get together at Tobey Maguire's house (his wife Jen just gave birth!), but you coulda worn something a little more fashionable than an old sweatshirt, jeans and flip-flops, right?
SEE THE GALLERY Nicky's Party Attire
Stories from around the Web