Simon Cowell and Carmen Electra are reportedly an item, and while we thought this was something from an episode of Punk'd, the unlikely duo were snapped embracing one another after leaving at Cecconi’s restaurant on Saturday!

The two went on another date Sunday, this time at at Ago in West Hollywood, and a source for In Touch Weekly says, “They were really into each other. At one point, they were talking real close, and he leaned in and kissed her. They started making out!"

Rumors began to swirl that the two were dating this spring after Carmen appeared as a guest judge with Simon on Britain’s Got Talent and dumped fiance Rob Patterson a few months later. When asked at the time why he chose the former Playmate, Simon joked, “She has the best set of … teeth I have ever seen."