Reese Witherspoon may be an Oscar winner with a seemingly perfect life, but it sounds like her husband Jim Toth might have opened a major can of worms after his DUI arrest in Atlanta on Friday morning!

Witherspoon and Toth were arrested after he was pulled over on suspicion of driving while intoxicated, and she was charged with disorderly conduct after disobeying a police officer who told her to stay inside the couple's car. Witherspoon apologized and said in a statement that she was "deeply embarrassed," adding that she had "clearly had one drink too many."

So what does this mean for the CAA agent, who represents stars like Matthew McConaughey, Jessica Alba and Robert Downey Jr.? A source close to Toth told People he "feels awful that he involved Reese in the situation ... He made a bad decision and it certainly made things worse that he dragged her into it." The insider added, "Jim has always been a big social drinker. A lot of his job is being social. He's out to lunch or dinner almost every day of the week, schmoozing clients and taking business meetings ... [The arrest is] just going to make the two of them stop and pause, and think about maybe how much Jim's drinking plays a role in their lives – if it does or not."

Another source tells the mag, "It's embarrassing for him. He'll have to explain himself to his bosses." Toth blew a .139 on his sobriety test, and yet another source tells the mag, "No one would be surprised if Jim goes to rehab."