Lindsay Lohan had some 'splaining to do!

While on Bravo's Watch What Happens Live last night, Andy Cohen nailed Lilo to the wall (okay more like politely asked and then cajoled) to get to the bottom of her notorious "personal conquest" list.

During a rousing game of Plead the Fifth, Lindsay was asked three questions in which she could only "plead the fifth" aka not answer -- one. The first question was whether or not her high-profile relationship with Samantha Ronson was the first time the "Mean Girls" star had dipped into the "lady pool," and the others were about the list that In Touch leaked last month with a list of famous men's names.

At first she hemmed and hawed about it but eventually got "serious" saying, ""That (list) was actually my fifth step in (Alcoholics Anonymous) at Betty Ford, and someone — when I was moving during the OWN show — must have taken a photo of it," she confessed. "So that's a really personal thing. It's really unfortunate ... 'cause it's just ... I talk about this on the last episode of the OWN show."

For those of you who are unawares, the fifth step is that we, "Admitted to God, ourselves, and to another human being the exact nature of our wrongs."

If this really is her fifth step that the fact that the list was leaked really is "unfortunate" to say the least, since we believe that recovery is a sacred time and truly should be kept anonymous. But truth be told, we have to wonder about the validity of Lindsay's claim; this list only has men's names -- we have a hard time believing that she hasn't wronged any women in her tumultuous 27 years on this planet. None? Seems doubtful to us.

Either way we really do hope that Lindsay is on the road to recovery because we've been hearing a lot of nasty rumors that she isn't sober. Remember Lindsay, one day at a time!