« Is Sam Lonely Without Lilo? | Main | X17 FACEOFF - Blonde Paris Vs. Brunette Paris! »
Idol Judge May Be Idle Next Season
Posted on Tue May 12, 2009 08:33 AM PDT
Rumors of in-fighting, jealousy and redundancy have plagued the fourth Idol judge, Kara DioGuardi, almost since she started on the show, but even the critic herself admits she's not sure whether or not she'll be back for another season.
“I hope I’m here for another season,” she told Gatecrasher, “but I haven’t been asked yet.”
So she's not "the dawg" like Randy, not entertainingly nonsensical like Paula and not as mean as Simon, but am I the only person who really liked what she brought to the table? She's younger and fresher than the other judges, plus, her critiques ring true as she's the only one who's worked as a pop singer (in this century), a producer and a song writer to some of the former Idols!
Do YOU think she should stay or should she go?
Photo Credit: Jack Guy/FOX
I say stay!
American Idol's Pia Toscano Opens Up About Plans For Future Album - Apr 12, 2011
Pia Toscano Eliminated From American Idol, Judges Angered By Decision - Apr 08, 2011
American Idol's Top 13 Contestants Are Revealed - Mar 04, 2011
Kellie Pickler's Wedding Video Now Available For Download On iTunes - Feb 24, 2011
American Idol's Ratings Take A Dip, But We Loved J Lo And Steven Tyler Last Night! - Jan 20, 2011
Comments
stay! i find her refreshing and honest, and people who dislike her are ridiculous and lack taste.
stay! i find her refreshing and honest, and people who dislike her are ridiculous and lacking taste.
Kick Paula and keep Kara. I don't like the 4 judge format because they talk too long, but Kara's opinions are much more informative than Paula's so Kara should be the one to stay.
i CAN'T stand her! she's soooo annoying!!! i hope she's not back next season!
can't stand her...hope she's not there next season!
please go!!!!! u don't belong!!!!!
Keep her getrid of paula...I LOVE SImon
Too boring, get rid of her. If she's this big song writer for majorstars she'll find another job.
Keep her!! She is awesome! She is actually makes sense! The contestants don't care at all what Paula says, they literally just wait for her to finish her awakward mumble and jumble! She is pathetic! Paula wants Simon and sees K as a threat! Let it go Paula, you are a washed up addicted to painkiller has been!
Keep her!! She is awesome! She is actually makes sense! The contestants don't care at all what Paula says, they literally just wait for her to finish her awakward mumble and jumble! She is pathetic! Paula wants Simon and sees K as a threat! Let it go Paula, you are a washed up addicted to painkiller has been!
Her comments/suggestions for each of the singers are great. I find her refreshing and real. The person that needs to go is Paula! Her time is up!!
She has got to go! She never has an opinion of her own. She always has to agree with Randy. She is completely useless.
Keep her. She is really hot and makes a lot of sense. Very nice to look at.
Be gone! Can't stand the annoying, know it all, fake bitch! She is Redundant! she better not come back, that's why I have lost interest in the show + the boring ugly ass contestants! Yuck!
She is fired!
she has to go! she's so annoying! paula is too, but i can stand her. i can't stand this one.
She needs to leave...NOW!
She needs to leave...NOW!
STAY!!! She's the most sincere. She actually critiques instead of goofing off for the camera like the rest of them. I think she knows her shit.
Paula is the one that should go Kara is right on Paula is a dingbat!
fired her she is the worst judges ever
I don't even watch the show anymore, it's too boring, but when I did I found that Paula was always in neutral, she always was the good person; no wrong was ever stated by her. She went with the flow and gave false hope. She isn't a good judge, she's a comedian trying to be a judge. Plus she was accused of trying to date one of the younger male contestants; that's a no no. Kick her ass out the door.
Keep her - what she says actually makes sense and she defeinitely knows music! I love Kara - she is my favourite judge this year and would be very upset if she didn't return next year. The advice she gives to eliminated contestants is 10x more useful than anything the other judges have ever said. On top of that, she has a great personality - she's fun, super sweet, and has a great rocker edge.
I know that people hate change but seriously, cut Kara some slack. Sure she's had a few slip-ups but she's big enough to just laugh at her mistakes to and you know what, the other judges have messed up too! And they've been doing this for eight seasons (remember Paula's slip-up of commenting about a second song before the contestant even sang it??). Kara is getting much better as the show goes on and ultimately, she deserves more credit for her contributions on American Idol.
the whole show needs togo...so boring.after adam being ripped off why bother watching. . its afarce
She has got to go!!!