Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement x17 France
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

« A Relaxed Rihanna In Stripes! | Main | BREAKING NEWS! - Rob Pattinson And Kristen Stewart Finally Give Us Proof They're A Couple! »

Lady Gaga Vs. Madonna: Who Has More Mojo?

Posted on Tue Nov 10, 2009 04:57 PM PDT

gagamadonnapoll.jpg

We loooooved Lady Gaga's new "Bad Romance" music vid earlier today!

We think her outrageous fashion is fresh, her music fun and her singing/writing/piano playing talents impressive... but can she really seriously be compared to Madonna's icon-level status already?

The Material Girl's secret? Always keep reinventing yourself. Will Gaga learn from her idol and stick around for the long haul?



I say YES!

Comments (0)
X17 Poll

Does Lady Gaga have Madonna's staying power?

YES, Lady Gaga is on her way to becoming a legend!
NO, Madonna is an original talent and Lady Gaga will soon be forgotten.
  • Vote
  • View Results

Comments



 

 


Note: Your comment will post in 5 minutes. Practice patience and don't double your efforts. Thank you.

Posted by: Anonymous

Neither, one is just costumes and the other made a career based on scandals and offencing christians.



Posted by: Flea

Whoever wrote this poll needs to remove the word "original" from the statement, 'Madonna is an original talent and Lady Gaga will soon be forgotten,' since neither one is original.

Madonna especially is guilty of being a second-rate copy cat, as she ripped off (yes, *ripped off*, not "paid homage to") so many other entertainers* over years that it's sad and pathetic.

*(such as but not limited to- Marlene Dietrich, Jean Harlow, Debbie Harry, Greta Garbo, Marilyn Monroe)



Posted by: Anonymous

Lady gaga is gifted ,She writes,composes,sings ,performs
all her songs



Posted by: Anonymous

Who Cares.



Posted by: Jay

Stop with the ridiculous comparisons already! I like GaGa and see potential in her but Madonna is an original artist and the only Queen. She's been a tour d' force for 30 years. She's the most successful female artist of all time, she's had more hit singles then anyone (besides the Beatles) and her last tour was the top grossing by a solo artist EVER. She has dozens of MTV awards, Grammys and is one of the top pop cultural icons of all time (along with the Beatles, Elivs, Monroe and MJ). Pop music, especially for females was completely different before Madonna. She made video a new medium and her brought music and art to another level. Her songs touched on subjects’ people wouldn’t dream singing about then (and some now) like abortion, domestic violence, death, religion, spirituality and most of all sex. W/o Madonna there'd be no GaGa, Britney, Rihanna, Gwen etc. To even compare then is ridiculous. Madonna songs are beyond classic, I like GaGa but she has yet to write a Like A Prayer, Express Yourself, Ray of Light, Vogue, Take a Bow, Music, Live to Tell, Hung Up etc. Madonna’s early songs might have come from other people but many of her best (previously mentioned) were by her. Plus Madonna is by far one of the greatest entertainers of all time. She's been the most famous woman in the world since 1984 for God’s sake. GaGa has had a few hits (so have Fergie, Rihanna, Gwen etc) but they aren't compared to icons. I find it ridiculous that people don't call Justin the new MJ b/c the same double standard doesn't exist for males as females. Madonna will be the Queen of Pop forever, simply b/c she was the first and the best. A copy is never as good as the original.



Posted by: Anonymous

Check out FlirtyGlam.com for all the hottest lingerie and swimwear



Posted by: Anonymous

Madonna was a professional dancer, ballet and modern, before she became a pop star. That is grueling, hard work. She had that foundation to sustain her work ethic and keep her going. If Gaga does, then good for her, but it's not easy. Just look at Britney, most of them can't cut it,



Posted by: Anonymous

Post 7:21 Don't compare Gaga to Modonna. Why even try. Gaga is new and Modonna is Modonna.



Posted by: Anonymous

Who is Modonna?



Posted by: Anonymous

There needs to be a neither button



Posted by: Anonymous

I TOTALLY AGREE WITH Jay !

you can't compare a newcomer to an ICON thats just ridiculous !!!!



Posted by: Anonymous

I TOTALLY AGREE WITH Jay !

you can't compare a newcomer to an ICON thats just ridiculous !!!!



Posted by: Maddyct

C'MON !!!!
Everyone knows Madonna is so much better !



Posted by: Anonymous

Who cares, they are both sell out's anyway!!!!



Posted by: Anonymous

Madonna is proof that skill at marketing is far more important (and more lucrative) than any actual performing talent.

This sad fact has brought us reality television, Britney Spears, George W. Bush, Lindsay Lohan, etc.



Posted by: Anonymous

They both SUCK!!!!!



Posted by: Karen

Madonna is a Queen and nobody will ever top her. She's been on top of the world since 1983 and will be an icon forever.



Posted by: E.E.

Shouldn't the comparison be
New vs Old? I say stick them both together on the next tour , sell tickets starting at 500 a pop and make billions. Be a hell of alot better than watching all the Michael Jackson crapola!



Posted by: Zaza

Maddona is Queen



Posted by: KC

"Her songs touched on subjects’ people wouldn’t dream singing about then (and some now) like abortion, domestic violence, death, religion, spirituality and most of all sex."

I hate to break it to you, sweety, but those subjects and more were touched upon long before Madonna came on the scene. Break out of your little bubble, and trying listening to music before 1984.



Posted by: BB

Cher - nobody mentions Cher - in my book Cher really rocked it with outragous stage outfits, powerful voice, nutty persona - she even had her own show in the 70's! - Tina Turner - another woman with a lot of positive sexuality -- Janis Joplin, Kate Bush, Debbie Harry - each generation has had very strong women on equal levels perform to audiences - And bringing back to present day - ever seen Juliette Lewis Live? And Paloma Faith? Lady Gaga is ace but she is not the only one to wear crazy outfits on stage right now!



Posted by: Anonymous

shesss a copycat



Advertisement
Gwen Stefani Hits The Beach With Her Boys
Advertisement
Kristen Stewart In Paris
Advertisement
Advertisement
Josh Hutcherson Buys Heath Ledger's Former Hollywood Treehouse For $2.5 Million
We Want Your Tips
Advertisement
Advertisement
Latest Celebrity Tweets
Advertisement
Celebrity Street Style
Advertisement
Like us on Facebook!
Advertisement
X17 Poll

What went wrong on The X Factor today with Britney Spears?

Britney definitely had another meltdown. This is proof she's not ready to step back into the spotlight!
I think Britney may have overreacted to a bad audition, but it will be entertaining to watch later!
I think Simon Cowell planned this all along. Brit probably even rehearsed it!
  • Vote
  • View Results
X17 on Twitter
Advertisement
Which actress looks best in her sexy red dress?
Scherzinger Kidman
VOTEVIEW RESULTS
Advertisement
Advertisement
X17 Exclusives