The couple that buys makeup together stays together? We're so confused!

On Friday afternoon Emma Roberts and Evan Peters went shopping at Sephora in Los Angeles, and the duo held hands when X17 photographers snapped them in the parking garage. While they've broken up and gotten back together more times than we can count over the years, the former American Horror Story co-stars reportedly ended their engagement just three months ago. Er, apparently not!

Emma and Evan got engaged around Christmas in 2013, and that was just six months after she was arrested for allegedly assaulting him in Montreal after an argument. These two just can't seem to make up their minds!